ProMatcher

What Type of Sump Pump is the Most Durable?

Top Answer: Submersible sump pump (51% of 68 votes).
What Type of Sump Pump is the Most Durable?
Pedestal sump pump
10%
Submersible sump pump
51%
There is no difference
25%
Not sure
13%

Get matched and get quotes from sump pump installers near you

Home | Sump Pump | Sump Pump Cost Reports | Sump Pump Contractors Directory

Updated on January 20, 2023

By

Comments From Our Pros

Answer: Not sure
Explanation: It at depends on the situation
One Call Services
Answer: Submersible sump pump
Explanation: Here's why: Sealed Motor, Heavy-Duty Construction, Quieter & More Powerful
Prime Plumbing
Answer: Submersible sump pump
Explanation: Submersible pumps are designed to operate underwater inside the sump pit, which helps cool the motor and reduce wear. They also tend to have a longer lifespan than pedestal sump pumps, which have an exposed motor that can be more prone to damage from moisture and debris.
Sibon Construction
ProMatcher
Answer: Submersible sump pump
Explanation: The submersible sump pump is more durable due to the fact that it is built for tougher jobs & they are larger and discharge from 3-5 times more than the Pedestal sump pump.
Midwest Restoration Pros LLC
Answer: Pedestal sump pump
Explanation: It would depend on the owner of the sump pump, to be honest. If this was a basement that was constantly at risk of floods the submersible sump pump would most likely be well worth its while. Otherwise, a pedestal pump is best and will stand the test of time, just not as powerful. Regardless, a well maintained sump pump will outlast neglected ones. So as long you remember to maintain the upkeep, you will be fine either or. Please refer to a professional. I'm always happy to help.
ServPro
Answer: Submersible sump pump
Explanation: I prefer using submersible, also raise them off bottom so no debris gets trapped below and clogs them
Diamond Contractors
ProMatcher
Answer: Not sure
Explanation: We do not offer this service
Srp
Answer: Pedestal sump pump
Explanation: Pedestal sump. Its cast iron and very tough
A&A Solutions LLC
Answer: Pedestal sump pump
Explanation: Pedestal sump pump will last longer it goes through less wear and tear
ERIK HOME SERVICES PLUMBER
ProMatcher
Answer: Pedestal sump pump
Explanation: Sub pumps that are submerged tend to last longer.
INCAN BUILDERS
Answer: Submersible sump pump
Explanation: Submersible sump pumps have self cooling motors (uses water as a coolant for the motor) so the pump will last much longer. In addition to the cooling properties the pumps impeller is always under water which creates a self priming situation, which means the pump will never go dry or need priming. Its also much quieter since the water insulates the sound. All together a submersible pump is a much better choice.
Inviso Services
Answer: Not sure
Explanation: We dont deal with alot of sump pumps in Hawaii.
Visionary General Contracting, LLC
ProMatcher
Answer: Submersible sump pump
Explanation: The best brands and durable sump pumps are submersible. They are meant to be installed as a home is being built and meant to be submerged under water.
Massimo Plumbing Services
Answer: There is no difference
Explanation: Just go with a dependable brand with a good warranty.
Plumbing Professionals
Answer: There is no difference
Explanation: Varies from manufacturer to manufacturer. You can't make a broad statement that a different design is more durable than the other.
Fresh Maintenance
ProMatcher
Answer: Submersible sump pump
Explanation: The submersible sump is more durable due to its better build. Most are built for tougher jobs than removing basic ground water. Submersible pumps are larger and discharge anywhere from 3 to 5 times more than what a pedestal pumps discharge. Always buy a brand name sump pump when replacing your old one.
Airtight Design Waterproofing
Answer: There is no difference
Explanation: both are made to stand a lot of use and abuse.
First American Cleaning & Restoration
Answer: Submersible sump pump
Explanation: Submersible are typically commercial grade and made with cast iron shell to last longer than most traditional plastic base pedestal pumps.
permanently closed
ProMatcher
Answer: Submersible sump pump
Explanation: Most simple type, so less likely to malfunction.
Dry Master Restoration, Inc.
Answer: Submersible sump pump
Explanation: I believe a sump is most important when there is a lower level or basement. If it is submerged into a pit and tied to drain tiles. I believe it is most effective in keeping water from your home and causing water damage. 98% of all water damages cause mold.
Mold Masters, Inc.
Answer: Pedestal sump pump
Explanation: personal experience
La Rose Home Repair
ProMatcher
Answer: Submersible sump pump
Explanation: It doesn't matter if it wet or under water
JD all service plumbing
Answer: Submersible sump pump
Explanation: This is the preferred pump in our area
First General Services
Answer: Submersible sump pump
Explanation: Because it pumps from underneath the water and stays cool form the water. It wont over heat like a pedestal pump would.
All City Construction
ProMatcher
Answer: Submersible sump pump
Explanation: In my experience, I mainly have dealt with submersible pumps. In my opinion they are built better to withstand water and are self priming when activated due to the water being able to cool the motor as it runs.
TruIntegrity LLC